Visit our new website:

Public Sector Mergers In India: Does Size Bring Synergies?

  • Sun, 13 Aug 2017 05:34

In June 2017, the $ 23 billion Vodafone-Idea Cellular merger got the go ahead from the Competition Commission of India. A few days later, the government announced a deal between two public sector undertakings (PSUs) – the Oil & Natural Gas Corporation (ONGC) and Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd (HPCL). The Rs. 28,000 crore ($ 4.4 billion) merger involves ONGC buying up the 51% government stake in HPCL.

India's debt/GDP ratio
myeviajes / Pixabay

In his Budget earlier this year, the finance minister had spoken of plans to merge the State Bank of India (SBI) with several of its subsidiaries; have four-five large PSU banks through a process of mergers; and a similar proposal to create oil giants. The SBI merger has happened; the first oil giant has been announced; and the other candidates in the size stakes are readying for action. Indian Oil Corporation (IOC) is waiting for permission to acquire Oil India, and the PSU banks — thanks to the new Reserve Bank of India (RBI) norms on bad assets — have begun writing on the same page. In another big league deal – though not a merger — IOC, Bharat Petroleum and HPCL have signed an agreement to set up a $ 30 billion refinery. The three companies will own 50%, 25% and 25% in the refinery, India’s biggest.

According to assurance, tax and advisory firm Grant Thornton, M&As in India almost doubled in the first half of 2017 to $ 35.84 billion, over the corresponding period of 2016. This was aided by the Vodafone merger. But, says Prashant Mehra, partner, Grant Thornton India, this is just the beginning.

Beyond the Public Sector

The trend is not just in government companies, where a merger doesn’t necessarily involve a change in management and ownership. It has spread to the private sector, too. Recently announced was a possible combine of IDFC, IDFC Bank and the Shriram Group. Piramal Enterprises chairman Ajay Piramal had acquired a 20% stake in Shriram Capital in 2014. He also owns similar holdings in Shriram Transport Finance and Shriram City Union Finance, effectively making him top honcho of the group. This proposed merger will create a financial services giant with a market capitalization of $ 10 billion. Other predators have been prowling around. Kotak Mahindra Bank and IndusInd Bank, both in the private sector, have been going up on the bourses after reports that they were wooing private sector financial services players.

Also in the private sector, another lot is seeking the security of mergers. Telecom companies – confronted with one giant (Vodafone-Idea) and another giant in the making (Reliance Jio, which has now upped the stakes by virtually offering free feature phones to its subscribers) — could be joining hands. “The Tata Group and Bharti Enterprises have held exploratory talks to evaluate a mega alliance involving their telecom, overseas cable and enterprise services, and direct-to-home TV businesses,” notes business daily The Economic Times.

Private sector mergers have their own watchdogs – shareholder interest groups, activists et al. Public sector mergers are mostly done just to balance the government’s books; the ONGC-HPCL merger is to meet this year’s disinvestment target of Rs. 72,500 crore. And using this method avoids the “selling the family silver” charges from opposition parties.

“We need to question the logic of public sector mergers,” says Ravi Aron, a professor of information systems at Johns Hopkins Carey Business School. “Usually efficiencies are achieved – if ever they are – by eliminating redundant functions and increasing productivity. To achieve these gains, it is necessary to reduce costs through layoffs. But in India retrenchment is taboo – both politically and through law. The Industrial Disputes Act makes it nearly impossible to effect large layoffs in non-managerial workers.”

“I believe it would be a mistake to only look at recent history … and ask what should be done next.” –Jitendra V. Singh

Exactly what efficiencies will be gained by mergers between public sector companies? “Before we discuss scale economies and synergies, it is important to understand what they mean,” Aron notes. “For scale economies to exist, it is necessary to reduce the average unit cost of production of a product or service with increasing volumes. That reduction in costs of production (more generally operating costs) can happen only if labor costs can be pared down. This is very difficult, given the Industrial Disputes Act. Perhaps they may slow down future hiring and drive some gains through voluntary retirement schemes. These gains are not likely to be very high.”

In a study titled “Making Public Sector Mergers Work: Lessons Learned,” Peter Frumkin, professor of social policy & practice at the University of Pennsylvania, writes: “There has yet to be much systematic thinking about what makes public sector mergers work and how best to carry them out. Beyond the assumption – which remains largely unproven — that government mergers produce greater levels of coordination and lead to cost savings through the reduction of roles and redundancies, the field is still in its infancy.” That is true even today, more than a decade after the study was first published.

But Mehra sees a silver lining. “Since it is all government owned, it helps in leveraging the infrastructure for better returns as it stops the common stakeholder (which is the government) effectively cannibalizing its own business.”

Looking at the Past

Jitendra V. Singh, emeritus professor of management at Wharton, says that one must look at the past to draw lessons for the future. He talks about the proposed sale of national carrier Air India. “I believe it would be a mistake to only look at the recent history of Air India and ask what should be done next,” he explains. “It is particularly instructive to look at a 50-year-plus span and learn lessons from the blunders made along the way. These lessons, if learned well, could be of much value to India in the future, if only so that they are not repeated in other settings.” Singh is referring in particular to the Air India-Indian Airlines merger, a marriage which created a money-guzzling monstrosity.

But Jitender Bhargava, former Air India executive director and the author of The Descent of Air India, feels that it would be the wrong example to draw any lessons from. “The Air India merger shouldn’t be used as a benchmark because it was scripted to fail, hastily pursued with malicious intent,” he says. “It was meant to squeeze whatever value was left in Air India to help private airlines.”

“The merger of the two poorly-performing, medium-sized airlines – Indian Airlines and Air India – did not create a large, well-run company,” says Aron. “It created a large drain on public finances and accumulated operating losses running into billions of dollars over several years.”

“The bigger the bank grows, the less accessible it becomes to the people.” –C.H. Venkatachalam

The other example which case studies are focusing on is SBI. The bank has had repeat experiences; the government had earlier merged it with the State Banks of Jaipur, Bikaner and Saurashtra. Even earlier (in 1969), it was the beleaguered State Bank of Bihar. The more recent mergers are still works in progress. “The merger is seen as a win-win for both SBI and

The post Public Sector Mergers In India: Does Size Bring Synergies? appeared first on ValueWalk.



Harvard Business Review

Related Stories

Galaxy S9 vs iPhone X: Will Samsung Copy All Apple’s Features?
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 20:36

The coming months will undoubtedly bear witness to a massive Galaxy S9 vs iPhone X battle. The new Samsung smartphone will compete against the premium...

Call to end 'deadweight' research and development tax breaks
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 19:31

Up to 80% of tax credits for research subsidises spending which would have happened anyway, report says. BBC News - Business

2 Sisters chicken supplier problems 'not one-off', say MPs
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 17:32

Supermarket meat supplier 2 Sisters had a "far from pristine" track record at one of its sites, MPs say. BBC News - Business

'Rehab Addict' Star Nicole Curtis Breastfeeds Her 2-1/2-Year-Old Son In Public and People Are Pissed
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 16:42

Post by Tanvier Peart. At some point, the whole "live and let live" motto will sink in. But sadly, today just is not that day. Nicole Curtis is being...

Mistrial in NY corruption case against union chief, hedge fund executive
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 16:37

NEW YORK (Reuters) - A U.S. judge on Thursday ordered a mistrial in the corruption case against the former head of New York City's correction officers...

Hedge fund bet on Glencore backfires with $100 million loss
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 15:31

LONDON (Reuters) - London hedge fund giant Lansdowne Partners lost $ 100 million from a long-term bet against Glencore this year after the spectacula...

Fundraising For Women-Run Venture Capital Funds Accelerates
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 14:46

Despite remaining underrepresented in the industry, women-owned funds are securing more capital and making more deals in 2017 .first{clear...

Strong Earnings For Small-Cap Cyclicals
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 13:53

Co-CIO Francis Gannon on the promising pace of small-cap earnings and what expanding global growth could mean for certain small-cap cyclicals. ...

Wells Fargo consumer lending head axed after disparaging regulators: source
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 12:45

NEW YORK/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Wells Fargo & Co announced on Friday it fired its head of consumer lending, a move that people familiar with the matte...

MOZAMBIQUE : World Bank increasingly playing nurse to mining sector
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 12:41

Africa Mining Intelligence

How Nepal’s cancelled dam scheme highlights country’s big debate: ally with India or China?
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 12:13

The question of whether Nepal should go ahead with plans to build a dam with a Chinese firm has become entwined in the wider debate about whether the ...

Budget 2017: Tax on takeaway boxes to be considered
  • Sat, 18 Nov 2017 10:35

The Chancellor is expected to announce plans to examine the idea in Wednesday's Budget. BBC News - Business

News Categories